| | Type of Date | Date of Game | Modern Address | Country | State | City | Home Team | Away Team |
|---|
| 'Citizens' v Crew of the USN Pinta in Sitka on 4 July 1886 | Day | | | United States | AK | Sitka | 'citizens' | Crew of the USN Pinta |
| 'Natives' v 'Haoles' in HI on 4 July 1866 | Day | | | United States | HI | | 'Natives' | 'Haoles' |
| 'colored juveniles' v 'colored juveniles' on 5 November 1867 | Day | | | United States | AL | Selma | 'colored juveniles' | 'colored juveniles' |
| 12th US Infantry v 25th US Infantry on 25 December 1899 | Day | | | Philippines | | | 12th US Infantry | 25th US Infantry |
| 14th Infantry v 9th Infantry on 15 October 1870 | Day | | | United States | WY | Fort Russell | 14th Infantry | 9th Infantry |
| 159th NY Infantry v 176th NY Infantry on 28 March 1865 | Day | | | United States | NC | Morehead City | 159th NY Infantry | 176th NY Infantry |
| 176th New York Infantry v 9th Connecticut Infantry in 1864 | Year | | | United States | LA | Madisonville | 176th New York Infantry | 9th Connecticut Infantry |
| 195th Pennsylvania Infantry v 195th Pennsylvania Infantry on 26 September 1865 | Day | | | United States | DC | Washington | 195th Pennsylvania Infantry | 195th Pennsylvania Infantry |
| 1st Nine of the Effingham BBC v 2nd Nine of the Effingham BBC on 12 July 1873 | Day | | | United States | IL | Mason | Effingham Base Ball Club | Effingham Base Ball Club |
| 1st Nine v 2d Nine on 29 November 1873 | Day | | | United States | CO | Fort Lyon | 1st Nine | 2d Nine |
| 24th United States Infantry Base Ball Club of Vicksburg, Mississippi v Crusaders Club of Vicksburg on 22 March 1867 | Day | | | United States | MS | Vicksburg | 24th United States Infantry Base Ball Club of Vicksburg, Mississippi | Crusaders Club of Vicksburg |
| 24th United States Infantry Base Ball Club of Vicksburg, Mississippi v Mississippi Valley BBC of Vicksburg on 10 February 1867 | Day | | | United States | MS | Vicksburg | 24th United States Infantry Base Ball Club of Vicksburg, Mississippi | Mississippi Valley BBC of Vicksburg |
| 24th United States Infantry Base Ball Club of Vicksburg, Mississippi v Mississippi Valley BBC of Vicksburg on 2 April 1867 | Day | | | United States | MS | Vicksburg | 24th United States Infantry Base Ball Club of Vicksburg, Mississippi | Mississippi Valley BBC of Vicksburg |
| 24th United States Infantry Base Ball Club of Vicksburg, Mississippi v Mississippi Valley BBC of Vicksburg on 7 February 1867 | Day | | | United States | MS | Vicksburg | 24th United States Infantry Base Ball Club of Vicksburg, Mississippi | Mississippi Valley BBC of Vicksburg |
| 2Empire Club of Newark v 2Adriatic Club of Newark on 7 October 1857 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Newark | Empire Club of Newark | Adriatic Club of Newark |
| 2nd Battalion, 133rd Infantry Regiment, 34th Division v 3rd Battalion, 133rd Infantry Regiment, 34th Division on 25 April 1942 | Day | | | Northern Ireland | | Belfast | 2nd Battalion, 133rd Infantry Regiment, 34th Division | 3rd Battalion, 133rd Infantry Regiment, 34th Division |
| 2nd nine v 1st nine on 10 October 1860 | Day | | | United States | NY | New York | Oraton Club of Newark | Oraton Club of Newark |
| 47th New York Infantry v 48th New York Infantry on 4 July 1865 | Day | | | United States | NC | Raleigh | 47th New York Infantry | 48th New York Infantry |
| 48th NY Infantry in 1862 | Year | | | United States | GA | Fort Pulaski | 48th NY Infantry | 48th NY Infantry |
| 48th NY Infantry v 48th NY Infantry on 7 March 1863 | Day | | | United States | GA | Fort Pulaski | 48th NY Infantry | 48th NY Infantry |
| 52nd Illinois Infantry Regiment v 2nd Iowa Regiment on 28 March 1863 | Day | | | United States | MS | Corinth | 52nd Illinois Infantry Regiment | 2nd Iowa Regiment |
| 60th NY v 78th NY in April 1864 | Month | | | United States | AL | Stevenson | 60th NY | 78th NY |
| 67th New York Infantry v 62nd New York Infantry on 19 April 1863 | Day | | | United States | VA | Falmouth | 67th New York Infantry | 62nd New York Infantry |
| 7th US Cavalry v 19th Kansas in 1869 | Year | | | United States | OK | Fort Sill | 7th US Cavalry | 19th Kansas |
| Abilene picked nine v Salina picked nine on 27 July 1876 | Day | | | United States | KS | Abilene | Abilene picked nine | Salina picked nine |
| Academy Club of Norwich v Uncas Club of Norwich on 1 July 1865 | Day | | | United States | CT | Norwich | Free Academy Club of Norwich | Uncas Club of Norwich |
| Academy Club of Trenton v National Club of Trenton on 4 November 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Trenton | Academy Club of Trenton | National Club of Trenton |
| Academy v Institute in Bloomfield on 22 August 1860 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Bloomfield | Academy | Institute |
| Accommodation Club of Fort Fetterman v Laramie Club of Fort Laramie in 1868 | Year | | Douglas WY | United States | WY | Fort Fetterman | Accommodation Club of Fort Fetterman | Laramie Club of Fort Laramie |
| Acme Club of Libertyville v Club of Highland Park in 1877 | Year | | | United States | IL | Half Day | Acme Club of Libertyville | Club of Highland Park |
| Acme Club of Waukegan v Lake Shore Club of Waukegan on 26 September 1867 | Day | | | United States | IL | Libertyville | Acme Club of Waukegan | Lake Shore Club of Waukegan |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Alert Club of South Orange on 16 November 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | South Orange | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Alert Club of Seton Hall of South Orange |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Alert Club of South Orange on 23 November 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | South Orange | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Alert Club of Seton Hall of South Orange |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Athletic Club of Philadelphia on 10 August 1865 | Day | | | United States | PA | Philadelphia | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Athletic Club of Philadelphia |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Atlantic Club of Brooklyn on 23 August 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Hoboken | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Atlantic Club of Brooklyn |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Club of Camden on 11 August 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Camden | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Club of Camden |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Eagle Base Ball Club of New York on 15 September 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Hoboken | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Eagle Base Ball Club of New York |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Empire Club of New York on 7 October 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Hoboken | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Empire Club of New York |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Empire Club of New York on 8 July 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Hoboken | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Empire Club of New York |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Enterprise Club of Brooklyn on 11 October 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Hoboken | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Enterprise Club of Brooklyn |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Enterprise Club of Brooklyn on 2 September 1865 | Day | | | United States | NY | Brooklyn | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Enterprise Club of Brooklyn |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Enterprise Club of Brooklyn on 29 July 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Hoboken | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Enterprise Club of Brooklyn |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Eureka Club of Newark on 20 October 1865 | Day | | | United States | NY | Brooklyn | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Eureka Club of Newark |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Gotham Club of New York on 18 October 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Hoboken | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Gotham Club of New York |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Gotham Club of New York on 29 September 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Hoboken | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Gotham Club of New York |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Gramercy Club of New York on 20 October 1865 | Day | | | United States | NY | New York | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Gramercy Club of New York |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Mutual Club of New York on 30 August 1865 | Day | | | United States | NJ | Hoboken | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Mutual Club of New York |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Olympic Club of Philadelphia on 9 August 1865 | Day | | | United States | PA | Philadelphia | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Olympic Club of Philadelphia |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Onalaska Club of New York on 2 October 1858 | Day | | | United States | NY | New York | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Onalaska Club of New York |
| Active Base Ball Club of New York v Onalaska Club of New York on 4 June 1859 | Day | | | United States | NY | New York | Active Base Ball Club of New York | Onalaska Club of New York |
