Alleghany Club v Pittsburg Club on 9 October 1857undefined

From Protoball
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Pre-pro Baseball

Add a Ballgame
Add a Predecessor Game
Add a Field
Add a Club
Add a Player
Add a Game Official

Base Ball Firsts
Add a Base Ball First

About Pre-pro
Waff's Game Tabulation
Bob Tholkes RIM Tabulation

Awaiting Review
Date of Game Friday, October 9, 1857
Location Pittsburgh, PA, United States
Home Team  Add Club Page Alleghany Club
Away Team  Add Club Page Pittsburg Club
Score 98 77
Has Source On Hand No
Innings 3 Game suspended by darkness
Number of Players 15
NY Rules No - Predecessor


"Pittsburg, Oct. 10

"Dear Spirit: Quite a large number of our citizens visited Alleghany, on last Friday, to witness the game of Base Ball, so long talked of, between the Pittsburg and Alleghany clubs.  The match was played by thirty men, equally divided, and consisted of three innings; but as it was dark before the Alleghanians finished their innings, they would not continue the game, so  the Pittsburg boys had to give in, after making nine runs in their third inning, and ten men still in [see note, below]. The result of the game was as follows."

[A box score shows Alleghany scoring 25, 24, and 49 runs in its three innings; Pittsburg scoring 31, 37, and 9 runs.]

"At the conclusion of the game there was some grumbling.  The Pittsburgers wanted the game to be played out; nor would they have commenced their third inning, only that they expected to finish the game.  The umpire, however, gave in his cohesion to the course that was followed, and ordered the game to be concluded on Saturday afternoon, a report of which I will give next week."

Note: Protoball's interpretation is that the game used all-out-side-out innings, and at the time of suspension only five of the fifteen Pittsburg club had been put out.

As described by Peter Morris in Base Ball Pioneers (McFarland, 2012), in 1904 the Pittsburgh Post reprinted the 1857 game account, and added the observations of a surviving participant, Michael Lynch.   Lynch said that the match was the "first baseball game played in Alleghany county, under the regulation rules and upon a regulation diamond," which Morris suggests may have meant that despite non-Knick rules for team size, innings played, and inning format, Knick field markings were employed.  Lynch recalled use of a "soft, rubber ball" that curved in flight and was hit to great distances. 

Some Protoball queries, 2015:  [1] Is there evidence that the game was completed? [2] Are we sure that the game used all-out-side-out innings? [3] Do we know of other similar games -- 15 players, AOSO innings, rubber balls, variant field layout, etc. -- in this region? [4] What is the "next day" account the Morris adverts to? [5] Was October 9 a Friday in 1857?

The Daily Pittsburgh Gazette, Oct. 10, 1857 page 3 carries an account of this game, giving a list of the players. Headlined "The Match of Base Ball." I checked the next 2 issues of the Gazette,, but they don't mention that the game was ever resumed. [ba]






Spirit of the Times, October 17, 1857.

Pittsburgh Post, April 4, 1904.

Peter Morris, "Alleghany Base Ball Club," Base Ball Pioneers (McFarland, 2012), pages 121-122.

Comment Edit with form to add a comment
Query Edit with form to add a query
Submitted by Bob Tholkes, Craig Britcher
Submission Note Emails of 6/23/2015


<comments voting="Plus" />